Kembali ke TOEFL Speaking B2 (4.0-4.5) English (US) – Take an Interview

Deciding Whether Attendance Should Count

Bahasa Inggris skenario berbicara

Thomas

A confident British English speaker with a balanced, formal delivery.

44 years · male

Practise talking about "Deciding Whether Attendance Should Count" with Thomas, your AI speaking avatar. Speak out loud, get instant feedback, and build confidence for your TOEFL iBT B2 speaking exam.

Start free AI practice

Percakapan

Why do some courses count attendance?

Kenapa beberapa mata kuliah menghitung kehadiran?

Jawaban yang bagus:

Some courses count attendance because participation is part of the learning. In seminars, language classes, or discussion-based courses, students learn by exchanging ideas, asking questions, and responding to classmates. If many students are absent, the quality of the class changes for everyone, not only for the missing students. Attendance can therefore support the course design. It reminds students that learning is not always a private activity that can be replaced by reading slides later at home. This is why attendance marks are more convincing when students actively contribute during class. Students should see that the mark reflects shared work, not just the teacher checking names.

Beberapa mata kuliah menghitung kehadiran karena partisipasi memang bagian dari proses belajar. Dalam seminar, kelas bahasa, atau mata kuliah yang berbasis diskusi, mahasiswa belajar dengan bertukar ide, mengajukan pertanyaan, dan menanggapi teman sekelas. Kalau banyak mahasiswa tidak hadir, kualitas kelas berubah untuk semua orang, bukan hanya untuk mahasiswa yang absen. Karena itu, kehadiran bisa mendukung rancangan mata kuliah. Kehadiran mengingatkan mahasiswa bahwa belajar tidak selalu merupakan kegiatan pribadi yang bisa digantikan dengan membaca slide nanti di rumah. Itulah sebabnya nilai kehadiran lebih meyakinkan ketika mahasiswa aktif berkontribusi selama kelas. Mahasiswa perlu melihat bahwa nilai itu mencerminkan kerja bersama, bukan sekadar dosen mengecek nama.

What problems can strict attendance rules create?

Jawaban yang bagus:

Strict attendance rules can be unfair to students with illness, caring responsibilities, disabilities, or unreliable transport. These students may lose marks even when they are trying to keep up with the course. A rule that looks simple on paper can affect students very differently in real life. For example, a commuter student may be late because of train cancellations, not lack of effort. Attendance policies should recognise genuine difficulties while still encouraging students to participate regularly when they can. A fair policy should include a process for explaining serious or repeated difficulties. Flexibility is especially important when the student can show they are still completing the work.

Should attendance affect grades, or should only performance matter?

Jawaban yang bagus:

I think performance should matter more, but attendance can count a little in classes where participation is central. The rule should match the course design. In a seminar or practical workshop, being present affects discussion, teamwork, and skill development. In that case, a small attendance or participation mark may be reasonable. However, it should not dominate the grade. Students should mainly be assessed on what they can understand, produce, explain, or apply, not simply on whether they were physically in the room. The weighting should be small enough that one difficult week does not damage the whole course result. That limit protects students from losing too many marks for circumstances beyond their control.

How could a course encourage attendance without being unfair?

Jawaban yang bagus:

A course could count participation tasks instead of simple presence. For example, students might submit a short discussion note, complete a group exercise, or answer a reflection question during class. This rewards students who engage, while still focusing on learning rather than seat time. It also gives teachers better evidence of participation. If a student misses class for a genuine reason, they might complete an alternative task. That approach encourages attendance without pretending that being present automatically means being involved. This kind of task also makes attendance feel purposeful rather than purely administrative. It also gives quieter students a structured way to show engagement.